Amy Schumer Lists Brooklyn Heights Townhouse for $14 Million

In late 2024, comedian Amy Schumer has made the decision to place her historic townhouse located in Brooklyn Heights on the market for a price of $14 million. This move comes as she prepares to return to Manhattan’s Upper West Side, where she had previously resided.

Acquisition and Renovation

Schumer, along with her husband, chef Chris Fischer, purchased the property—a Federal-style residence dating back to the early 1800s—for approximately $12.3 million in the summer of 2022. Following the acquisition, the couple undertook extensive renovations to customize the home, aligning it with their personal preferences and lifestyle.

A Historical Gem

This notable townhouse is recognized for its role as the Castorini family’s home in the acclaimed 1987 film Moonstruck, which starred Cher and Nicolas Cage. The brick structure features a distinct mansard roof and measures 26 feet in width. It offers a generous living space of over 5,500 square feet, encompassing four to potentially five bedrooms and four bathrooms across five levels. The residence is designed to maximize natural light, boasting an impressive total of 30 windows.

Key Features and Layout

Noteworthy aspects of the home include:

• A chef’s kitchen featuring exposed beams, wide-plank flooring, custom wood cabinetry, and high-end appliances by Gaggenau and Lacanche, alongside a butler’s pantry, and a cozy breakfast nook.
• On the second level, the main entrance opens to two elegantly appointed parlors separated by pocket doors, a powder room, and access to an iron-railed terrace leading to the backyard.
• The third floor houses a luxurious primary suite complete with an original fireplace, multiple sitting areas, and a marble-clad bathroom outfitted with dual vanities and a vintage clawfoot soaking tub.
• The top floor features additional bedrooms with a shared penny-tiled bathroom and laundry facilities, alongside a Miele washer and dryer.
• The basement is a well-appointed space that includes a custom wine cellar, an excavated gym, and laundry amenities.

Motivation Behind the Sale

According to reports from The Wall Street Journal, Schumer’s decision to sell the Brooklyn residence is motivated by her family’s desire to be closer to their son’s school in Manhattan. She remarked, “He got into a good school, and we’re too lazy to commute 45 minutes to take our son to school every day.”

Conclusion

As Amy Schumer transitions back to Manhattan, the sale of her Brooklyn Heights townhouse marks another chapter in her journey as a public figure managing life, family, and career in New York City.

For additional visuals of the Brooklyn residence, click here.