Moving to a New Home Could Cost Existing U.S. Homeowners 85 Percent More Each Month

Diane Whitfield|
Moving truck filled with boxes and furniture outside a house in a landscaped area

Realtor.com research reveals how higher mortgage rates and home prices are discouraging homeowners from moving.

Millions of American homeowners face a difficult financial decision when considering whether to sell their existing properties and purchase new homes. A new Realtor.com housing analysis released November 11 found that the typical mortgage holder would need approximately $1,100 more per month in principal and interest to purchase a median-priced home at current market financing conditions.

The estimated payment would increase from approximately $1,332 to $2,468, representing an 85.3 percent rise.

The findings illustrate the continuing impact of the mortgage lock-in effect, which occurs when homeowners with older, lower-interest loans are discouraged from moving because replacing their mortgages would significantly increase monthly expenses.

The issue has become an important factor in the American residential housing market, influencing the availability of existing homes and the decisions of families considering relocation.

Why Homeowners Are Staying Put

The difference between existing and current mortgage rates is central to the problem.

According to the research, the typical outstanding mortgage carries an interest rate of approximately 4 percent. The payment estimate for purchasing a median-priced home uses a mortgage rate of 7.32 percent.

For homeowners who secured financing during the low-rate period of 2020 and 2021, moving could mean surrendering a favorable mortgage and accepting a substantially more expensive loan.

The resulting payment difference can influence decisions involving family size, employment, retirement and relocation.

A household that needs additional space may decide to remain in its current property rather than assume a much larger monthly payment.

Similarly, homeowners considering downsizing may discover that purchasing another property does not necessarily provide the expected financial relief.

These decisions contribute to reduced movement within the residential market.

The Effect on Available Housing Inventory

The mortgage lock-in effect can influence housing supply because existing homeowners are also an important source of properties for sale.

When households postpone selling, fewer previously occupied homes enter the market.

That can reduce the choices available to buyers, particularly in established neighborhoods where new construction is limited.

The relationship between mortgage rates and housing inventory is not straightforward, because new listings also depend on employment changes, household formation, construction activity and personal circumstances.

Nevertheless, the financial incentive to retain an older mortgage provides an additional reason for homeowners to delay selling.

This can create challenges for buyers seeking properties in locations where available inventory is already limited.

Affordability Varies by Metropolitan Area

The report identifies significant differences among major metropolitan housing markets.

San Jose, California, Portland, Maine, and Los Angeles are among the areas where existing mortgage holders face particularly steep payment increases when considering a purchase at current median prices.

By comparison, Pittsburgh, Baltimore and Buffalo are among the least locked-in markets in the research.

These differences demonstrate that the mortgage lock-in effect is influenced by more than national interest rates.

Local home prices and the interest rates attached to outstanding mortgages also play important roles.

In expensive metropolitan markets, a homeowner may face a particularly large financial gap between an existing loan and a replacement property.

In more affordable areas, the difference may be less pronounced.

Would Lower Mortgage Rates Solve the Problem?

The research also examined the effect of lower mortgage rates on housing affordability.

It estimated that rates would need to reach 6 percent or below for half of households to afford a median-priced home under the report's affordability assumptions.

Even under that scenario, the typical mortgage holder would still face a payment approximately 61.7 percent higher than the current principal and interest expense.

This suggests that the affordability challenge cannot be explained by interest rates alone.

Home prices and household incomes remain important factors in determining whether a property is financially accessible.

The cost of property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance and other expenses can further influence the total cost of homeownership.

The report's payment comparison focuses on principal and interest, meaning that the actual financial difference between properties may vary depending on these additional costs.

Consequences for Buyers and Sellers

For buyers, the findings help explain why the existing-home market can remain difficult even when some homeowners express interest in selling.

The supply of available properties depends partly on whether existing owners can afford to move.

For sellers, the research highlights the importance of comparing current market values with the cost of purchasing a replacement home.

A homeowner may have substantial equity but still face a difficult affordability calculation when evaluating a new mortgage.

Residential agents also need to understand these financial considerations when working with clients who are uncertain about moving.

The market may require more detailed conversations about financing, property values and long-term housing requirements.

A Market Defined by Limited Mobility

The latest research shows that the American housing market is being shaped by a financial divide between existing homeowners and prospective buyers.

Households holding older mortgages may benefit from lower payments but face reduced flexibility when considering a move.

Meanwhile, buyers entering the market must account for current financing costs and property prices.

The estimated 85.3 percent increase in monthly payments illustrates the scale of the challenge.

As mortgage rates and housing prices continue influencing residential decisions, the lock-in effect remains an important factor in understanding homeownership, resale inventory and housing mobility across the United States.

Share
Best Houses

Best Houses Contributor

Diane Whitfield

Covers residential real estate and the agents behind it, from listings and design to the deals that close.


This article features partner, contributor, or branded content from a third party. Members of the Best Houses editorial staff were not involved in the creation of this content. All views and opinions are those of the contributor alone.

You May Also Like

More from Residential